HK COVID-19 Daily Report: Day 255 — November 26, 2020 | Garbage In, Garbage Out

So at some point in the not-too-distant future, a person says to their robot… “Please go to the grocery store and get two steaks. And if they have eggs, get a dozen.” And the robot goes to the store, and comes back with… a dozen steaks.

This is a popular joke among computer programmers, because they’re the ones who get it right away. Indeed, computers are only as good as what you put into them, and the programming error that would lead to the twelve steaks is a common one. With computers, you need to be specific. You can’t make assumptions. If told to get steaks, it will get steaks. Computers aren’t smart enough to read into the obvious subtext that the human brain picks up instantly… and this is why the errors in the B.C. data that came to light yesterday can only be blamed on human error. Officially labelled “an IT error”, it’s more colloquially known as a “B.C.K. error” — Between Chair and Keyboard. Another common computer saying: Garbage In, Garbage Out. I’m thinking there may be someone looking for a job.

We don’t need to single out the health authority that messed up… but if you’re curious, their name sort of rhymes with “laser stealth”. Or “blazer wealth”. Given that it’s actually the provincial health region with the most cases, screw-ups there could make a difference to where we think things are at. Did it?

The ultimate changes are reflected in today’s numbers; all corrections have been applied, and I’m assuming with today’s data, we’re back on track. If you want to compare, you can flip back to yesterday’s post and see what changed. Side-note, if you’re looking at yesterday’s post, feel free to have a look at the comments, especially near the bottom…

Anyway, after it all shakes out, the end result isn’t too different. The provincial case count is 271 more than had previously been thought, a discrepancy of less than one percent. The interesting thing is how it got there… undercounts *and* overcounts. I could understand if there was data missing every day… or, double-counted, so bigger-than-expected numbers here and there. But both? That’s just… really bad.

The 271 isn’t a big deal, but what might have made a difference would’ve been the “shape” of the numbers. We’d all thought we had this massive day of 941 new cases. That never happened. That day only had 706. The “big” day was Nov 21st, with 835. Except, of course, this is changing by the day… and you can ignore all of that, because, unfortunately, the B.C. record for number of new cases was set… today, at 887. And don’t expect it to last too long.
What as I was saying about the “shape” of cases was simply this: Let’s say there were 5,000 new cases over the last 5 days. There’s a big difference… if those 5 days looked like 300, 489, 797, 1299, 2115… vs. 1000, 1000, 1000, 1000, 1000. Or, of course, 2115, 1299, 797, 489, 300. Those are three very different stories being told.

As it turns out, if anything, the corrected numbers served to “flatten” the look a bit. But again, not materially relevant.

At the end of the day, these graphs, charts, and ultimate analysis are only as good as what goes into it. As per above, Garbage In, Garbage Out.

Follow & Discuss on Facebook

Originally published at https://kemeny.ca on November 27, 2020.

--

--

--

Covid-19 graphs and analysis with personal reflections | Posted and discussed on facebook.com/kemeny.ca | Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada | kemeny.ca

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

FIFA 2019 Player Information

Areas of Population Growth

Pandas to PySpark in 6 Examples

“Minority Report”​: Real life edition

8 Ways To Royally Flummox Your Data — and Not Even Know It

Data Collection Companies for Machine Learning

What do we need to be data driven?: A gentle guide for the future

A Graph is a Visual Argument, Not a Fact

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Horatio Kemeny

Horatio Kemeny

Covid-19 graphs and analysis with personal reflections | Posted and discussed on facebook.com/kemeny.ca | Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada | kemeny.ca

More from Medium

What is the Difference between Inductive and Deductive Argument Reasoning?

Earthquakes and Seismographs

CodeHS Student Journey: From High School to Syracuse University

GridMatrix Exhibits at Inaugural California Mobility Showcase